Quote from: Michael Schulman, The New Yorker, 18 April 2025In his historic career, Stephen Sondheim stripped the American musical of its schmaltz, tapping into the curdled emotions underneath. In Stephen Sondheim's Old Friends, a posthumous revue imported from the West End, the producer Cameron Mackintosh and the director Matthew Bourne smear it back on, giving Sondheim's complicated œuvre the sheen of supper-club entertainment. Bernadette Peters and Lea Salonga lead the cast, decked out in spangles and tuxes, as they cycle through the hits —"Send in the Clowns," "Broadway Baby," "The Ladies Who Lunch"— and deploy the occasional kickline. The evening lacks Sondheim's ironic bite, but, if you love his musicals, you could do worse than hearing Peters, his preëminent muse, sing "Losing My Mind." Featuring Beth Leavel, for shameless scene-stealing. —Michael Schulman (Samuel J. Friedman; through June 15.)